Attorneys General Request Suspension of Medicare 5 Star Rating System for Nursing Homes

Dan Frith

Contributor

0 CommentsPrint ArticleSubscribe

Thirty state attorneys general have asked the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) to suspend and revise its Five-Star rating system. The Five-Star system, launched in December 2008, gives each nursing facility a rating between one and five stars, based on the facility’s inspection record, staffing levels, and “quality measures” (e.g., percentage of residents with pressure sores or urinary tract infections).

In short, the Five-Star system grades facilities on a curve within a state, and the attorneys general are requesting ratings that could be compared from state to state. It is unclear how much of an issue this is for consumers, since in most (but not all) cases the search for a facility is done solely within one state.

A copy of the request is available on the National Senior Citizens Law Center (NSCLC) website.

My Take: Attorneys General are politicians and money is the financial life-blood of any successful politician. My guess is that deep-pocketed owners of nursing homes made a little telephone call to their state's attorney general and told them the money will stop unless you help us. Unfortunately, the politicians decided money for re-election was more important than informing the public about which nursing homes in their state provide poor care. A sad commentary indeed!